BJ’s Pizookie Flavors, Ranked: Calories and Prices

The BJ’s menu includes several full-size Pizookie flavors, plus the Pizookie Trio and Kids’ Mini Pizookie. The exact selection can vary by location. Our ranking below will help you decide which one to order. Our top pick is the Triple Chocolate Pizookie Made with Ghirardelli.

This ranking is our editorial judgment. We ranked the flavors by flavor profile, richness, distinctiveness, and how well each option suits different preferences. BJ’s does not rank its own flavors.

Prices shown are reference prices from Virginia Gateway in Gainesville, VA, verified October 1, 2026. Prices vary by restaurant, so your local price may differ.

BJ’s Pizookie Flavors at a Glance

BJ’s official nutrition guide confirms calories for only some pizookie flavors. Where BJ’s does not publish a verified value for the exact item, we show “Not listed” rather than estimating.

Prices shown are from Virginia Gateway in Gainesville, VA. BJ’s prices vary by restaurant.

BJ’s Pizookie Flavors, Ranked

1. Triple Chocolate Made with Ghirardelli

We put this first for its chocolate depth. It uses Ghirardelli chocolate, giving it a distinct chocolate profile. It is a rich dessert, so consider sharing it. The Triple Chocolate Pizookie Made with Ghirardelli has the full item details on its page.

2. Salted Caramel

We rank this second for distinctiveness. The salt balances the caramel sweetness and gives it a sweet-and-salty profile the other flavors do not have. If you want something other than chocolate, this is our pick.

3. Chocolate Chunk

Chocolate Chunk is the straightforward choice for a classic chocolate-cookie flavor. It has no extra mix-ins, which makes it the easiest recommendation when the people at your table want different things.

4. Cookies ’n’ Cream

Cookie pieces run through the dough, which gives this pizookie more texture than the others. It has 1,350 confirmed calories, the highest confirmed value among the full-size flavors with a verified calorie figure. Plan to share it.

5. Strawberry Shortcake

Strawberry and cream give this option a different profile from the chocolate-heavy flavors. We rank it here for anyone who wants a fruit-based dessert instead of chocolate.

6. Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip

This is the option for gluten-sensitive diners. It keeps the chocolate chip cookie format in a gluten-sensitive recipe. BJ’s kitchens use shared preparation areas, so ask your restaurant about preparation if you have celiac disease.

7. Sugar Cookie

The simplest flavor in the lineup. It has 1,160 confirmed calories, the lowest confirmed value among the full-size flavors with a verified calorie figure. We rank it last on flavor interest: it is a fine choice if you prefer a plain vanilla-cookie base.

What About the Pizookie Trio?

The trio is three mini pizookies in the flavors you choose, priced at $14.99 at our reference location. Calories range from 1,740 to 2,180 depending on the three flavors selected. The Pizookie Trio gives groups three mini pizookies to share, which makes it the practical pick when the table wants variety.

What About the Kids’ Mini Pizookie?

The kids’ menu includes a smaller pizookie at $5.99 at our reference location. It is portioned for one child rather than for sharing.

How Much Is a Pizookie at BJ’s?

A full-size Pizookie is $9.49 at the Virginia Gateway location used as our reference. The trio is $14.99 and the kids’ mini is $5.99 at the same reference location. BJ’s prices vary by restaurant, so your local price may differ.

What Is a Pizookie?

A pizookie is a warm cookie baked in a small deep-dish pan and served with ice cream. The name combines “pizza” and “cookie.” BJ’s serves it in the pan it is baked in.

Pizookie FAQ

How many people does a pizookie feed?

A full-size pizookie arrives as one skillet. The trio is the option built for groups that want to share or sample more than one flavor.

Why do some flavors show “Not listed” for calories?

BJ’s publishes verified nutrition values for only some menu items. Where BJ’s does not publish a value for the exact item and serving size, we show “Not listed” instead of estimating.

The Short Version

If you want one recommendation, order the Triple Chocolate Made with Ghirardelli. For something different, try the salted caramel. For a group, get the trio. All full-size flavors cost the same at our reference location, so the choice comes down to taste. The BJ’s menu also includes pizzas, burgers, pastas, and other desserts if you are planning the full order.